ANALYSIS

The worrying trend of Celtic’s creativity problem and squad decline

Celtic's chance creation has had a steep decline this season. <i>(Image: NQ)</i>
Celtic's chance creation has had a steep decline this season. (Image: NQ)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Celtic’s extraordinary penalty shoot-out win over Rangers without a single shot was an anomaly, but the data this season reveals a worrying decline in creativity that could yet shape the title race. Analyst Alan Morrison digs into the issue and considers a potential solution, for now.


Performances that lead to results like Celtic's victory at Ibrox on Sunday, where a side can have no shots at all yet win on penalties, are not unique in football. It is why we love the sport, in part.

It is low-scoring by design: scoring goals is difficult and celebrated so much because of their rarity. The laws and structures of the sport mean that a team of lesser ability can frustrate a supposedly superior opponent and still find time and space to score on the break or from a set piece. Or not at all!

Therefore, Sunday’s outcome does not defy analysis as such. A mixture of poor opposition creative passing and finishing, solid Celtic goalkeeper play, brave and concentrated defending, and a bit of luck, are all 'normal' football variance factors.

Game with five Celtic shots or less. (Image: Alan Morrison)

Celtic have had 19 instances of getting five shots or fewer away since 2014. Most are in European away matches, or derbies. Having no shots at all is unique in this time frame, and if any reader knows when the last time Celtic had zero efforts at goal in a match, please let me know.

It does highlight a concern for this injury-ravaged, ragtag, Celtic side patched together with loanees, youngsters, those who wanted away, and those who should be squad players at best.

Here is the xG per 90 minutes generated across all games in all competitions.

Celtic's all-competition xG trend across seasons. (Image: Alan Morrison)

This season is the lowest on record, even worse than the epic failure of the 2020-21 COVID-19 campaign.

Under Ange Postecoglou and then Brendan Rodgers, Celtic regularly topped 2.5 xG. And bear in mind this season has seen no Champions League level opponents unlike some of those seasons.

The failure to replace Kyogo Furuhashi, and indeed Adam Idah, Giorgos Giakoumakis and Oh Hyeon-gyu for goodness sake, has been impactful. Neither Tamas Cvancara nor Junior Adamu has provided immediate dividend. Daizen Maeda is preferred off the left. Kelechi Iheanacho seems to be erratically available. I joked on the podcast referenced above Celtic should bring back Johnny Kenny. (I wasn’t joking).

Most of the new strikers don’t yet have the 900 minimum minutes for analysis so today the question is, “Where are the goal chances going to come from?”

Chance Creation

The following view combines key passes – a pass that leads directly to a shot at goal – with passes into the box – passes completed into the opponent's penalty area as an indicator of getting the ball into dangerous areas. Both per 90.

Celtic creativity squad comparison in 2025/26. (Image: Statsbomb)

It is fortunate indeed that the worst fears many of us had regarding Kieran Tierney’s fitness have been unfounded, as he has completed 3028 minutes so far. His absence on Sunday was a huge blow for the team, but it came because of a reckless challenge at Aberdeen rather than the attritional muscle injuries many have suffered. Small mercies.

He has been a standout for the club this season in terms of chance creation. Tierney is successful with 25 per cent of his crosses and completes 1.43 passes into the danger zone per game, more than all but occasional starters Luke McCowan and James Forrest.

Indeed, McCowan is the second most prominent on this chart, yet has been treated as a substitute by Rodgers and Martin O’Neill, and was only considered a starter by Wilfried Nancy, whom he criticised. Some players don’t know they’re born!

The other regular midfielders are not producing to this level, although Sebastian Tounekti has the highest rate of key passes.

In particular, the paucity of wing play that creates chances is stark. Neither Maeda nor Yang Hyun-jun can match even the more goal-oriented Benjamin Nygren. Yang’s rate is more akin to Anthony Ralston, and Maeda’s to deep-lying playmaker Callum McGregor.

The lack of quality creativity from the wide areas, in a team that sets up with two wide forwards, has been a glaring issue for Celtic.

How does this compare to prior, more productive seasons?

2024/25

Last season under Brendan Rodgers was dominant. The league was won with 92 points, a gap of 17 back to second, and 112 goals scored.

In terms of the creative passing:

Celtic creativity squad comparison in 2024/25. (Image: Statsbomb)

We remember the late-season James Forrest flourish, which was just as well, as by that stage Nicolas Kuhn’s early-season hot streak had cooled somewhat. But both were nudging towards 2.5 key passes per 90 minutes in league play.

Both Hatate and Arne Engels showed far more creative prowess last season compared to this. McCowan again showed, when used, a flair for creativity.

They were supplemented by solid contributions from all the full-backs.

Whether it was Greg Taylor from central positions or overlapping from Alistair Johnston or Anthony Ralston. There was a variety and a range of angles of attack.

Both Maeda and Yang were low in comparison, but at higher levels than this season.

2022/23

This was Postecoglou’s second and dominant season. The team achieved 99 points and 114 goals. This season and the one above should be the benchmarks for what remains a resource-dominant club.

Celtic creativity squad comparison in 2022/23. (Image: Statsbomb)

This is where I get a bit sad.

Whereas I’d posit that 2024/25 was a triumph of good coaching with relatively meagre talent, this season saw Celtic with an abundance of creative talent.

Note the scales on the graphs – this one goes up to 2.9 key passes per game.

Around the 2.5 mark is an array of players whose creative quality simply isn’t available: David Turnbull, Matt O’Riley, Aaron Mooy, Liel Abada, Jota and the much-maligned and misunderstood Sead Haksabanovic. The Montenegrin was a highly creative “10” miscast as a one-paced winger.

Hatate was the least creative of that cadre and yet is now the one Celtic look to as the main fulcrum.

Again, all the full-backs pitched in.


None of today’s tales reveals new information. The squad quality has been allowed to decline, especially in the attacking areas. Sunday’s zero-shot performance encapsulated that.

Only really Tierney and Jota, consistently, and Hatate erratically, of the current squad could be relied upon to provide anything like the levels of creative passing needed compared to the benchmarked seasons.

What to do?

Especially at home, where Celtic can exert more control over both the ball and field position, I’d be tempted to go with Tounekti and McCowan on the wings. Hatate and Nygren plus McGregor is a horribly unathletic midfield, but when dominating the ball, probably the least bad option.

Meanwhile, fixing this mess must be one of many priorities for the depleted recruitment operation.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos